Little Girl Gone by Gerry Schmitt

While not my favorite genre, I do occasionally enjoy a good crime thriller, including everything Dennis Lehane has ever written. While I wasn't paying attention, a new subgenre has suddenly emerged, or at very least been named: "cozy" mysteries. And if you follow that link to its Wikipedia entry, it reads like an outline for this book, Little Girl Gone by Gerry Schmitt. Female protagonist is an amateur detective in a small community with good instincts and a relationship to the police department so she can get insider info to solve the crime, which is bad but not too graphic. While I'm not knocking this book for that or the job that the author did writing it, it seems a little formulaic somehow, as though she went through the "checklist" and made sure she had all the right elements.

Also, given that we know from the outset who did the crime, this book is about watching the main character, Afton Tangler (say what? Is she a hair product?), connect the dots and solve the crime by chasing down one dead end lead after another. Since I brought up the Dennis Lehane thing, lets compare a bit to Gone Baby Gone (which if he wrote it today would probably have to be called Gone Girl Gone because every title needs a "Girl" in it now for some reason). Same premise, little girl goes missing, detectives, amateur or otherwise, on the case trying to find her. And in Baby, you don't know who took her or why, so you're there in the minds of the detectives trying to piece it all together right along with them. In Girl, there really is no mystery, just a tangled plot with some halfway interesting characters. Final beef, I love that Afton (Really? It's a town in Wyoming, a river in Scotland, a chemical company, but a girl's name?) is a rockclimber, and Schmitt got a lot of details right, and then some crucial ones wrong. Nitpicky, I know, but whenever an author tries to take on my sport it really irks me to have to read incorrect climbing scenes. Will I check out Book #2 in the Afton Tangler series? (Tangler - to bring together in intricate confusion, which is an apt definition, and a 58 point word in Scrabble.) Probably, if only because it'll give me more opportunities to think of snarky things to say about her name.